American Idol 8 Top 2. Oh, Kahra. That song is so awful.
Oh, oh, oh. Y’all, I can’t say how exciting excited I am. I can try, though. Two more eps of Idol and my little snarking fingers get a rest.
Not that I’m not ultra-stoked about American Idol this week. Ryan says it’s down to the guy next door versus the guyliner. That’s cute. Oh, Pauler. You had a choice of three dresses tonight (so she tweeted–YES! I’m following her on Twitter, because I’m a loser and because her crazy is my crack!), and you went with the lime sherbet. I hope that means you’ve got Crazy Juice in your Coke cup!

Great. Ryan says they’ll run long tomorrow night, so we should set our DVRs accordingly.
01 Adam will first sing “Mad World.” And, um, Jackson Rathbone says to vote for Adam tonight. I’m so gonna hate to disappoint him. Unless Kris (a boy) sucks, in which case I’ll vote Adam. Adam comes out in the smoke, and he’s wearing a duster, so backlit it looks like a dress. This is probably his happiest Idol moment. He’s great on the song (until, surprisingly, the last note, which is pitchydawg until it straightens itself out). Maybe a little glam for the song? Well done. RANDY: Yo man. A’ight, so check it out. This is IT. We’re down to the wire, it’s Kahra’s next-to-last show, I love the performance, I love the fog. A+ on that one, dude. A for Adam. KAHRA: I’m so happy you chose that performance. Wow, can I talk. If there were an Olympic event called Marathon Talking, I would win gold. I love gold so much. Can I emote about gold for a while? I’m not even half done here, peeps. Go read the entire works of Shakespeare and then come back, and maybe I’ll still be talking. SARAHK: Seriously, I can’t even listen to her. POH-LAR: Adam, bask in your moment. This is still haunting. The theatrical taste of what we’re going to see. Good job. SIMON: I always thought this was your best performance throughout the show. For some reason, maybe it was the coat, it was a little bit over-theatrical. It just reminded me a little of Phantom of the Opera. RANDY: No, Twilight! ALICE: Yeah, Twilight! Very broody.
02 Kris, a boy regardless of the way he and Kris Kristofferson spell their name, used to charge his parents to sing for them. It’s either very cute or very douchebaggy. Kris is gonna do “Ain’t No Sunshine,” and he’s at the piano. When he did this one before, it was one of his best, IIRC. I really kinda like him at the piano, because when he’s there they mostly film him in profile, so we don’t get the weird twisty faces. Eeeeeee! This was brill. His wifey agrees. Simon looks afraid. Potential for the chosen one to lose! RANDY: Check it out. It’s been said about great basketball teams. This is the funny thing about you. I can tell exactly what kind of artist you’re gonna be. I haven’t seen the rest of the night, but dude, you saved the best for last! One of your best performances ever on this stage! SARAHK: Yes. KAHRA: If you can’t emote about a Kris Allen performance, there’s something wrong with me. SARAHK: There’s something so very wrong with you. PAULER: Kris, you awaken the spirit of vodka in all of us. You trademark something or other and it’s the true marking of a great artist. SIMON: I’m gonna be honest with you. When your name was announced last week, I wasn’t sure America made the right choice. But after that performance, I take all of that back. RYAN: Simon, Round 1, who wins? SIMON: I’m gonna call that one for Kris. SARAHK: Yay! Me too!
Don’t forget to download them on iTunes. Last year, we couldn’t download anything after the finale. I don’t know if that’s what they’ll do this year.
01 Simon Fuller picked “Change is Gonna Come” for Adam. I have an icky feeling about this round–a sabotagey feeling. Adam loves his shiny suits, no? Oh. The hand gestures. I can’t take it. He’s so very diva right now. The singing is fantastic, but this is the first time I’ve ever considered closing my eyes during his performance. Whew. Gonna be hard for Kris to beat that one. RANDY: Yo, dude. That song is an amazing R&B classic by the great Sam Cook. What you did there was showed that the real reason you’re here, you can sing your face off. Unbelievable. KAHRA: Adam? Adam? SARAHK: She says his name twice, and already I’m tense and angry. It’s almost like she’s won. She’s made me street rat crazy. SPIKE: Don’t give up yet, pet. I believe in you. KAHRA: Blah blah blah, best ever singing in the history of histories, and I really mean it, and you know I mean it, because I say it so forcefully and with much pounding of the table. Is there anyone who doesn’t think I mean it? Ok, I’ll emote some more. SARAHK: Kill me, Spike. Kill me quickly. SPIKE: ‘Twould be a crime to damage an artist such as yourself. But since I can’t have you following– SARAHK: UNGH! Put down the sword! SPIKE: Sorry, love. PAULER: Adam, that was the best I’ve ever heard you sing, ever, ever, ever! Woo! [She stands up and lassos the air! Yay Crazy Paula! Where’ve you been hiding? I love you, girlfriend. You complete me.] PAULER: Whatever happens, I know with every fiber of my being, you are going to be iconic! SPIKE: Did she get the spray tan? SARAH: Yes. SIMON: Poh-lar’s sort of sitting on the fence after that one. All I can say, since Kahra took up all the judging time, is that put you back in the game tonight.
Lookie there. Tom let Katie out of the house tonight. It’s a special night, indeed.
My Sister’s Keeper looks like pretty much the dumbest movie ever. It’s gotta be based on a Nicholas Sparks novel. [I’ve been informed by my cousin Megs that it’s Jodi Picoult.]
02 Kris, a boy, was sabotaged with “What’s Goin’ On,” and I hereby proclaim Simon Fuller to be a toolshed. Full of all kinds of tools, that guy. Nevertheless, he comes out with the guitar, all Mrazzy, and makes me feel like I’m chillin’ out, maxin’, relaxin’, etc. I love it. RANDY: Check it out, baby. We’ve got ourselves a real live competition. It’s a good song choice, you sang it great, it’s just a little light for me. SARAHK: What? KAHRA: You’ve been true to yourself since day one. I like that Simon Fuller picked a socially conscious song for you. SARAHK: See? I tried to listen, and she lost me. If I cared about socially conscious messages on Idol, I would have voted for the Archtweener of Moralizing. Anyway, Kahra makes me want to cut myself. PAULER: I know what’s goin’ on. You tore that song up and made Marvin Gaye proud! SIMON: I love the song, but if I’m being honest with you, it was like three friends in their bedroom. You didn’t in my opinion grab hold of the song, make it your version, and I thought it was too laid back for a night like this. Sorry. RYAN: At the end of round two, who does it go to? SIMON: Oh. Million percent Adam. SARAHK: Well, there’s only so much you can do with an exec producer sabotage, Cowell.
01 The Sappy First Single(TM) was cowritten by Kahra. And… I’m near speechless, because either this song is written to be atonal and a giant mess, or Adam is so very pitchydawg. I mean, this is a disaster. My mouth, it hangs open. Maybe they should have done this song first. Yuck. Even the crowd is having a hard time loving that. RANDY: Yo. I said it before, I’ll say it again. Dude, you can sing anything, you can sing the phone book. But that was not one of my favorite Adam performances, it was just a’ight for me. To be honest with you. It was a little pitchy in spots for me. SARAHK: In spots?? SPIKE: In all the spots. SARAH: It was a giant mess. Absolute disaster. KAHRA: Adam, you made it sound like I can’t write music. SARAHK: And she actually can, she cowrote a song on Kelly Clarkson’s latest, and I don’t remember hating it. KAHRA: Adam, I think I speak on behalf of my cowriters, I’ll name them though no one cares. It’s great to hear someone of your level singing that song. I’m moved and I’m proud, and I thank you for giving me that moment here at the end. SPIKE: Of my Idol career. SARAHK: Notice she didn’t say it was good. PAULER: Very proud. Very proud of you. Adam. Adjectives cannot express what you’ve brought to this show, to season eight. SARAHK: Maybe you should try nouns? PAULER: I’m in awe. You can sing whatever you wanna sing, and I’ll be a fan forever, front in line. SIMON: It’s the mountains and the hurricanes. I’m not gonna judge that song, I’m gonna judge you. You’ve been one of the most original contestants we’ve ever had on the show. The whole idea of doing a show like this is that you can find a worldwide star. I genuinely believe that we have found that with you. Congratulations. SARAHK: Also? Not a good finish.
If Glee isn’t awesome, I’m gonna be mad at all the time they spent pimping it on Idol.
02 I have to watch Kris’s mountains-and-hurricans song with my eyes closed. Oh no. He forgot the words in the first chorus. Oh wow–it wasn’t Adam, it’s a giant mess of a song. Kris is doing the best he can with “No Boundaries.” He doesn’t sound nearly as pitchy, and it’s just good they both had to sing that. Blerg. But he was better on it. RANDY: You should be very proud of what you did in this competition. You’re an amazing competitor. I actually think that song kinda fit your voice kinda better for me than even Adam. KAHRA: I don’t want you to be judged on that song, it was a little high for you. Also, I’m embarrassed that I cowrote it, because yikes, right? You’re compelling, you’ve come into your own. I hope people will judge you on the season. I emotively hope so. SARAHK: I emotively hope that was the last judgment you’ll make on Idol. But I will give you this: there’s no way I would have liked you, you were doomed for me from the beginning, and that’s unfair of me. Even if you hadn’t been so dreadful and painfully emotive, I wouldn’t have liked you. So part of it isn’t your fault. Like 1% of it isn’t your fault. PAULER: I think you should take it in. You’ve done an amazing job. This has been one of the most compelling finales and final showdowns. I wish you the best of luck. You deserve where you are in that spotlight. SIMON: Kris, again, I think your highlight tonight was the first song you sang. Really. But I think watching you tonight on this stage has been incredible. Because I can remember your first audition where you came in, no confidence, weren’t sure how good you were. Your mum & dad’s face tells me everything. They’re very very proud of you, as they should be. And you have thoroughly deserved to be standing on this stage tonight. KRIS: Thank you Simon. SARAH: I love this. I love how Kris has personally thanked every judge after their critiques, in a deep Elvisy way. It’s cracking me up.
Oh, what a nice surprise! My Carrie’s out to sing “Home Sweet Home.” Highlight reel and all that.
Just to be clear. I will buy both their albums. Kris is more my kind of music, and I think he’s gotten better every week. Adam’s been the same for the last several weeks, and I dig him just a little less. But tonight… I’m all for Kris. Maybe it’s the underdog thing, maybe it’s because I love his voice and the acoustic thing… Whatevs.
I actually think Kris won it tonight. Being honest. Two out of three rounds go to Kris. I’m fine with the results either way, but I’m voting one way.
Kris (voted for him like a million times)
Adam (didn’t vote, because we’re down to two, and I have to pick one).
Alice? ALICE: No one will buy the first single. No matter who wins. SARAHK: And I predict that… Um… Hard one. Adam is expected to win, but Danny voters could go Kris’s way… Only a million separated them last week… Um… Adam is the next American Idol.



May 20th, 2009 at 2:09 am
[…] Over at Snark Raving Mad. […]
May 20th, 2009 at 10:35 am
So Round 1 was DEFinitely Kris. Adam, once again, repeated an annoying performance. Kris, on the other hand, changed up a phenomenal performance.
Round 2….fine Adam was ok on his “Socially Conscious” choice. The hand gestures were getting ridiculous, reminding me of that one contestant (forgot the name). The one that was in the all girl group that ended up very dramatic. Nate something? It wasn’t pleasant, suffice it to say. Kris was awesome as per usual, in spite of the fact that they gave him another “Socially Conscious” song.
Round 3. Wow. That song. Is terrible. First of all, it’s like it was written for Adam’s voice. The key and everything. Luckily for us, Adam still couldn’t hack it. Kris, I’m not sure if that was a “forget the words” moment or just “I can’t believe I really have to sing this terrible song” moment. But regardless it was still 100% more enjoyable than Adam’s.
By the by, is it really Kahra’s only season of Idol????? I truly hope so.
This is always a bittersweet time for me, because the blog fun ends….
May 20th, 2009 at 10:58 am
Oh, Jess. I’m just HOPING it’s Kahra’s last season. Because seriously. I don’t know of a single person who likes her as an AI judge. And not in a we-love-to-hate-Kara kind of way. In a I-might-not-watch-next-year-if-she’s-still-on kind of way.
May 20th, 2009 at 10:59 am
I’ve been enjoying AI for years, but never voted. The kids got me to let them vote last week: they voted for all three guys….they also voted tonight: for Ch(K)ris.
I was an Adam fan early on, didn’t like Ch(K)ris in the beginning (don’t even remember what he sang early on), but I luv him now!
My gut tells me it’ll be Ch(K)ris. Adam will be just fine without the “title”.
Why do they make those kids sing teh horrible songs every year? Kara is a professional songwritter? That song sounded like it came for a high school music class. BAAAAADDDD!
May 20th, 2009 at 10:59 am
P.S. I’m actually starting to think my prediction is wrong. I think Kris, a boy, is gonna pull it out.
May 20th, 2009 at 11:03 am
Hi SarahK…
Long time reader, first time poster here. (Frank, or more specifically imao sent me).
But noooooo! You can’t stop now! What will I do at work? You must find something else to blog! If they hadn’t delayed Glee until the fall, you’d have your answer. I guess you’ll have to go back to t-shirt/handgun modelling. Damn!
May 20th, 2009 at 11:03 am
Yeah, the song was so bad and Kara looked so horrified hearing it live that I almost think she didn’t write it but the producers asked her to put her name on it or something.
It was so bad that I actually googled “Inside Your Heaven” to see if her name was on that one, too.
I loved how all four judges were like, um, we’re not gonna judge you on the song. Simon was like it’s rainbows and hurricanes, and Kahra was in the background going, “I know, I know.” Like “Yes, I realize I no longer have credibility. Or friends.”
May 20th, 2009 at 11:06 am
Buck, thank you for not wanting it to be over.
I will find lots of things to write about, but I don’t know what they’ll be and whether there will be snark. But if there’s no snark, I’ll at least blog something on both sites.
May 20th, 2009 at 11:31 am
Change is comin’ folks. I can feel it. Man, all I had to do is listen to a show orchestrated by a couple of the most successful, wealthy, entrepreneurial businessmen in the music biz’ and I BELIEVE! Yes we can!! The songs they chose for these two dudes last night, wow, it made me THINK. I am UPLIFTED. (Hand waving up and down with finger and thumb formed in a perfect “O”). I am CHANGED! That’s right. I changed the channel.
The show was a red-carpet throw down for tonight’s special guest. Wait for it…wait for it…..who’s a’comin’? CHANGE is a’comin! I HOPE. Predicted by ME. On this site, March 27th.
Thanks to SarahK (and all the voices in her head) for the best Idol snark in cyberspace. I’ll miss it.
May 20th, 2009 at 11:35 am
Thanks, Ginger.
Y’all don’t go away just yet! There’s still the finale tonight, which will keep me up until the wee hours.
May 20th, 2009 at 1:37 pm
Missed Idol live. I have it on DVR, but managed to catch Glee live.
I enjoyed Glee. I don’t like the spastic wife heading towards a failed marriage with an obvious affair being setup for the main character. But I like the student story, even if the melodrama is high (though funny that a show about “glee” kids would have tons of melodrama, I think that must be part of the hook). The final scene did give me more chills than any performance on Idol this year, even with the lead boy singer having a weak voice.
As for Idol, I was never a fan of Kris. Sorry, just got nothing from his singing. I think Adam has tons of talent, but I’m no fan of his style of music. So when Gokey went home, I tuned out. Curiousity and the greatness of SarahK’s writing makes me come here and read what’s still going on. So instead of catching up with the DVR, I watched the DWTS results. Those results surprised me.
May 20th, 2009 at 1:46 pm
Thanks. :) Let me know what you think about Kahra’s deer-in-headlights look after they sing the song she cowrote. It’s beautiful.
Haven’t watched Glee yet. Will watch tonight or tomorrow night. The DWTS results didn’t surprise me. I got to watch the Monday night show for once, and Shawn was hands-down the best in the freestyle. A little boring in the paso, but whatevs.
May 20th, 2009 at 2:06 pm
DWTS for me too. I thought over the whole season, Gilles was the best dancer and I just expected he would win. But Shawn’s freestyle was amazing, and Gilles had a weak night (for him). Did anyone watch the comedian’s roast (can’t think of his name)? Whoa. I ’spose like any roast, some really uncomfortable moments - and some that were just priceless.
May 20th, 2009 at 2:16 pm
Amazing snark, Sarahk! You never disappoint!
And I voted. I ACTUALLY voted. I haven’t voted since Kelly Clarkson.
For Kris, btw.
May 20th, 2009 at 2:19 pm
Tracey, that means so much coming from you! I love you.
and yay, I’m glad you voted for my man!
May 20th, 2009 at 10:32 pm
Hey Snarky,
You just gotta belive hon. :D High Five. Allen Wins idol title. :D
Cheers
Arne
May 20th, 2009 at 10:38 pm
SarahK, Please blog what you think of Glee. I’m on the fence.
By the way. What are you doing in 24 days? Cause I think you and FrankJ should come to our wedding. Even though we don’t “really” know you. That would be awesome.
Oh. And Paul turned 24 on the same day as the season finale of 24. I made him brownies and put candles in them so they looked like a digital 24 when they were all lit. It was cool. Cooler than that lame-o ending. KILL KIM BAUER!
May 21st, 2009 at 1:59 am
Arne, hi-5! Kris is WIN!
Jessica, I like it. I’m going to watch it again tomorrow with Frank and decide if I love it.
May 30th, 2009 at 7:12 pm
Oh my… finally watched the last two “competition” performances.
Randy just lied that the song fit Kris’s voice better. And yes, Kara’s eyes when Randy says that, just before she begs people to forget that song.
I think Daughtry could have made that song sound good. Maybe… With that huge orchestra behind him, because the instrumental was better than the vocales, but maybe. Adam took a good shot, but Adam’s desire to hair band yell just wasn’t the style of a “let me pick you up with inspiration.”
Otherwise, my life was not really enriched by listening to the last few minutes of Idol competition as compared to the last few minutes of Glee. Lea Michele is talented.