American Idol 8 Top 3. Shut up, Kahra. Just shut up. Forever.
It’s the 300th episode of… American Idol. I know, you thought I was gonna say America’s Next Top Model, what with Adam doing his little turn on the catwalk, but you’re wrong.
Two songs each tonight: The Judges’ Sabotage and the singer’s choice.
01 Pauler decided to sabotage Danny with fervor by picking a Terence Trent D’Arby song. No lie, srsly. “Dance Little Sister.” He’s doing as well as we can expect from a song by this artist. Actually, better. I’m liking his voice, energy, look. The dancing was silly. Luv ya, Danns. RANDY: Let the games begin, right? Way to jump it off. Dude, that was dope for me. KAHRA: I like that you picked that, because it keeps him in his money spot. The dancing was too gyrating for me. Let me emote for a while. PAULER: I’m a choreographer, and I think you did… REALLY GOOD! SPIKE: SUCK IT, KAHRA! PAULER: And what’s great is you let that magic part of your voice carry through the rest of the song, and I thought you did a fantastic job. SIMON: Just to remind the girls, it’s a singing show, not that funny little dancing show, whatever it is, next door. I agree with Kahra, the dancing was desperate. The singing was very good. What I didn’t like was the toy saxophone solo in the middle of the song. And Pauler was on the right track with Terence Trent D’Arby, but I would have picked a different song. SIMON is trying to smother Pauler. RYAN: Paula has just punched Simon in the left breast. SARAHK: He will be massaging it during the next segment. And that was crappy of them to play while they’re giving out Danny’s number.
02 Haha. Kahra and Randy are coupled, don’t get their own picks. They decided Kahra can’t be trusted alone, and Simon and Paula don’t like her. Dude, Kris (a boy) has my phone. I hate that phone. Randy and Kahra have chosen “Apologize” by One Republic for Kris. Kahra says they picked it because everyone knows it. Well, I don’t off the top of my head. Oh, now that he’s singing, yes, I have heard it. Kris is at the piano. I didn’t know he played. Has he done this before this season and it was just during his forgettable period? Anyway. He’s having a little trouble with the high falsetto notes but other than that he’s really good. Well done. RANDY: We’re down to the top three. You can have a song like that and it’ll sell millions of records. This is who you are. KAHRA: I think it was a really competent performance, but at this stage, you’ve gotta be swinging it out of the park. She goes on and on about how she didn’t like the song or something. SARAHK: Definitely more competent than Kahra’s judging. PAULER: I’m used to you taking artistic license. There was a loud, bum note. But I’m so proud of you. Good job. SIMON: How can you say there’s a bum note, I’m so proud of you. Kahra, it’s a copout what you said. You cahn’t choose a song for him and then blame him for doing the song. KAHRA: Have you ever interpreted a song? I don’t think so. SARAHK: Shut up, harlot. Just shut up. Forever. SIMON: What you should have done, what I did, if you want him to play on the guitar, you should play on the guitar. You [Kahra and Randy] didn’t hold up your end of the bargain. SIMON has spent his entire judging time dissing Kahra and Randy. RANDY: I didn’t know we could arrange the songs! SIMON: You didn’t ahhsk. SARAHK: Simon, will you marry me? SPIKE: Me too? Wait. I mean, thanks. Just thanks. No marriage.
03 Adam got a text from Simon Cowell. He’s to sing “One” by U2. Gooooood choice. He had to get permission from the band, because they personally have to clear each song. SIMON: I personally got a call from Bono on Saturday saying they would be honored to have him sing the song. SARAHK: Namedropper! SPIKE: Randy! ADAM is taking this low-key. Ok, in the beginning only. Hmm. I’m surprised. I’m not liking it. He’s screechy and holy crap, PITCHYDAWG? Dude. I did not see that coming. RANDY: Yo. You are definitely still in the zone. Unbelievable vocals. A little for me going off the melody, I’m not sure I liked that so much. SIMON: Booooo. SARAHK: hahahaha. KAHRA: You’re an amazing strategist. Blaaaaaaahblaaaaaaahblaaaaaah. Unbelievable. Emote. Emote. Emote. PAULER: I’m so miserable. Sitting next to him gloating. ADAM: Just punch him again. PAULER: It was One brilliant song. One superb performance. And One American Idol that I’m staring at right now. SIMON: That was a brilliant song choice. But you find a great artist, a great song, you worked out what you wanted to do with it. And I have to say if you’re not in the final next week, it will be one of the biggest upsets. SARAHK: Pushing one contestant much?
I cannot WAIT for Land of the Lost. June 5th, baby. Seeing it. If for no other reason than: SLEESTAKS!
I’m confused, because Ryan’s giving an update on Idol Gives Back, which they didn’t do. $140MM has been raised through Idol Gives Back. Exxon/Mobil took Carrie Underwood to Angola this year. In case y’all don’t know, I totally have a girlcrush on Carrie. SPIKE: We knew, love.
01 Danny is singing “You Are So Beautiful” by Joe Cocker. I wouldn’t have chosen this song for him. I’ve gotta say, I rolled my eyes HARD when they announced the song. Not by the end, because it was lovely. Too airy at first, but by the end, I was bobbing and nodding and swooning. RANDY: You can really really really sing! Mad vocals, dude. KAHRA: Everything you didn’t do in the first performance for me, you just did. How emotionally can I say the word “stunning”? I’ll try it a few different ways. PAULER: You nailed it. It was a beautiful, beautiful performance! SIMON: I love the song, wouldn’t have done the arrangement. Having said that, it is a singing competition. I would call that a vocal master class. SARAHK: Yes. Thank you. Relieved sigh. Danny, stop talking. Just stop. Let me bask. Kthx.
02 Kris (still a boy) is singing “Heartless” by Kanye West. Okay then. I pay no attention to Kanye West, so I don’t know what this should sound like. But, um, I’m loving this. Other than the fact that he apparently inherited Allison’s enunciation issues (I’m so racist! Against white people!). But then he sings “me” pronounced “may,” and I’m totally won over, because that’s totally a JT thing, and I heart it so GOOD. This is… well, it’s the best of the night so far for me. RANDY: I like that version better than the Fray’s version, better than Kanye’s version. KAHRA: Why didn’t you do that with “Apologize”? EMOTION! I HAZ IT! FOR LONG PERIODS OF TIME! SARAHK: Shut up, Kahra. Just shut up. Forever. Do not pass go, do not collect $200. Just shut your face. PAULER: You’re the bravest artist, because you sang a song that’s about Simon Cowell. And I commend you. Bravo. SIMON: After what I thought was quite a lame song choice (the first song), I had literally written you out of this competition. That, however, has all changed after that song. SARAHK: Agreed. Dang.
03 Adam’s gonna do Aerosmith’s “Cryin’.” Wow. Before the first chorus, he’s pitchydawg again! It’s a whole different Adam tonight. I’m shocked but after this, I have to put him in 3rd place! Of course by the end of the song, I’m in awe. So I’m totally torn. I don’t know. Still screechy. I scratch my head. Did I say wow? RANDY: You’re one of the best that we’ve ever had on this stage. I love this even more than “One” for you. KAHRA: How do you hit those notes and still talk the next day? Oh, I could have ended it there, but I’ll go on. We’ll see you at the finals. PAULER: If Steven Tyler was a mentor, he wouldn’t have anything to say. We’ll be seeing you next week and many years after that. SIMON: I’m not gonna suck up as much as the other three. It’s very easy to assume that you’re going to sail through to the final. I don’t want everyone to assume you’ll be there but to vote for you based on talent. ADAM: I think Kris and Danny did really well tonight. We’ll see what happens. SARAHK: I think Kris was better than you overall, for sure. Let’s watch the recap.
Here’s my order:
Kris
Danny, who was not pitchydawg
Adam, who was pitchydawg on both songs. But it’s really close. Three ways close.
Alice? ALICE: Yeah, so… I see Adam in the finals. The judges have pre-ordained it. And you’ll be shocked to know that Kris is in the finals as well. Danny goes home but gets a record deal and charms the socks off SarahK for years to come. They all get record deals, actually.
SARAHK: I think Kris is the only one of Danny and Kris who has a chance to beat Adam. And I think he was the best tonight.
14 Snarkbacks to “American Idol 8 Top 3. Shut up, Kahra. Just shut up. Forever.”
Snarkback!
You must be logged in to post a comment.



May 13th, 2009 at 3:29 am
I CONCUR!!!!!!! Kris was AMAZING. My thumbs hurt from voting incessantly for him. If he does make it to next week, I’m considering paying people to vote for him. It would be sweet sweet victory to see Kris beat Adam in a knock down dragout sing-off.
And Kahra is almost as annoying as a rock in your shoe.
Oh one more thing.
Adam sucks.
May 13th, 2009 at 7:49 am
Totally agree. The judge’s Adam love has sucked all the credibility out of the show this season. Kris was GREAt last night, we had four phones going for him at our house. I doubt if the show would “let” Kris win, but he’s be awesome in the finals!
May 13th, 2009 at 8:21 am
[…] I do every Tuesday night and Wednesday night. Last night’s Idol surprised […]
May 13th, 2009 at 8:41 am
Have you noticed that all three finalists look like movie stars?
Danny looks like Robert Downey Jr.
Adam looks like Kurt Russell.
Kris looks like Brad Pitt.
Freaky!
May 13th, 2009 at 8:57 am
Oh deah…I didn’t love “One.” Adam could have KILLED with that song but he just HAD to do his screechy thang. Tsk. And “Cryin’ ” was ATROOOCIOUS! oh Adam Adam Adam, why, WHY?!
My second favorite, Kris, (a boy) was very good on “Apologize”. I don’t know “Heartless” but I didn’t love it. By the way, when he did “Falling Slowly” a few weeks ago, it was a STUNNER.
For once, and ONLY once, I can see that Danny had a good night. That sax part (in Dance Little Sister) was extraneous and DID sound like a toy sax. (I bought one eons ago and my cats loved it. I was the Pied Piper when I played it for them. But to do that on a big night? Not so smart. There’s only one Adam who can do something like that and it doesn’t always work for him either.) He DID do a decent “You are So Beautiful.” There, I finally gave him some props.
But only Adam is worthy of the American Idol title. Maybe if we beg, he’ll keep those high notes on the downlow next time.
I PRAY that it’s between Adam and Kris. It should have been Allison, but it’s ‘too late to apologize’ for her ouster.
May 13th, 2009 at 10:07 am
Ack – Adam. He was unbearable last night. Come on! Enough with the screeching. If nothing else, it’s just getting a bit boring. Adam’s actually a pretty likeable guy and supremely talented (I mean, geesh, you’d think he was a seasoned pro who’s had years of experience working a stage which, of course, makes him the ONLY one worthy of being our Idol, ROCK GOD and all). But based on tonight, the mouthpiece judges might be shocked, SHOCKED, to see him voted off. Ignorant ‘mericans just don’t know talent when it’s shoved down their throats. I’m wondering if he wasn’t pulling a Daughtry. He’s gonna do fine, wealth and fame and all, but if he gets out now and has that killer CD in his future – profits are all his. Not under the production thumb of the Idol machinery. We’ll see.
Kahra is like that annoying older sister whose mannerisms drive you crazy. How about the way she puts her thumb and first finger into an O and waves it up and down in time to her nonstop blathering? She just needs to stop that.
Danny sang beautifully and with heart. Kris has earned his spot. I was glad he showcased his instrumental talents – piano and guitar. My husband has found him a snoozer the entire season but finally got won over last night with “Heartless.”
The rebel in me would love to be pleasantly surprised and find Kris and Danny as our top 2. Probably won’t happen but it would be fun to watch heads explode. Of course another surprise would be if our President shows up to give out the award (as I predicted on this site and has since been strongly hinted at in the media), Adam wins and surprises our Other American Idol with a question about what he thinks about gay marriage. That would be fun too.
May 13th, 2009 at 10:45 am
Love you SarahK, Spike and Alice! I hit my bookmark to read you before I skim SirLinksALot! I voted my thumbs off for Kris. (Did you know he’s a boy?) Srsly disappointed in Adam’s singing last night, but not his speaking. Class act and a gentleman. I wouldn’t buy a rock CD full of screeches, though if he did one of ballads, yum.
Well, if we’re voting on just last night, Kris and Gokey were the best, IMNSHO (in my not so humble opinion) Loved Gokey’s you are so beautiful, though I have to listen to the playback - I thought he went flat at the end of the first and second bar. The rest was beyond lovely and worthy of Simon’s accolade. That was his only stand out moment for me in the series, umm not counting the peel the paint dying cat screech of last week which will live in infamy. If we’re voting on performance over the season, it’s Kris and Adam for me, kinda the way David Cook won though I thought Archie did a better finale.
And if Upstairs is listening, it’ll be Kris and Adam in the finale, and I’ll vote on whoever sings best that night.
May 13th, 2009 at 11:11 am
[…] ready! I blogged Idol at Snark Raving Mad last night. Go read it and then tell me if you agree that Kara’s the worst thing that ever happened to American Idol. Possibly the worst thing to ever exist. (No Ratings Yet) Loading […]
May 13th, 2009 at 12:16 pm
Can’t wait to catch up on this… but re: movie star Idols - my Ladybug calls Kris “Hal Sparks.” Spot-on.
May 13th, 2009 at 1:50 pm
Wow! I thought I was the only person in the world who didn’t love Adam’s singing last night. He screeched his way through both songs. I think the judges have pumped him up so much that he doesn’t believe he can fail. I would not buy an album he put out but I do see myself buying a Danny/Kris cd. I have stumbled into an alter universe here at Snark Raving Mad via lmao! Can’t wait to see what happens tonight and subsequently read about it here tomorrow!
May 13th, 2009 at 2:31 pm
Danny was solid on both performances. Kris meh on the first, wow on the second. Adam blew both. Danny and Kris for the final. Adam needs to go…if nothing else because he has been the recipient of such blatant favoritism… getting the pimp spot for the 4th TIME!!!! And major judge interference on his behalf. sickening.
May 13th, 2009 at 10:35 pm
Are you kidding? Adam WANTS to be sent home! I know it’s late, but I have not heard or seen anything regarding tonight’s vote. Do you think he wants to be controled by the AI producers fro his first album? He’s way too creative.
I think a final between Kris and Danny would be exciting. I didn’t like Kris until midway though, but he’s quietly grown and done a great job!
May 14th, 2009 at 7:52 pm
I concur with you on every point. Because we are simpatico. Also geniuses.
For the first time since Kelly Clarkson, I actually voted the other night. Numerous times. For Kris AND Danny.
It would be a major upset if Kris won, but I’m rooting for him. He’s the most versatile and, I think, the most commercial of the top three. Just what do you DO with Adam Lambert?
(I had a whole post about this on my blog, but, poof! it’s gone.)
May 14th, 2009 at 7:59 pm
We are all of these things you say.
And I concur with you that Kris is the most commercial. He’s just come on full-steam in the past six or so weeks. If the guy can write songs, my former fake boyfriend Jason Mraz had better watch out.
Adam can front a rock band, but I feel like he needs to replace the lead singer of an already-established band and not start his own. I don’t know why I think that. Maybe because he sounds so much like Axl Rose to me.
I am very upset with your blog, poofing your posts as it has been. But you know, it started happening around the time my comments started posting with lightning speed. Which is to say if the two items are related, it’s a cruel universe, and I don’t want to live in it anymore.